Quick-Sear Seafood Medley with Garlic Butter

By Laura TideUpdated:
Seafood Medley in 20 Minutes featuring seared scallops, pink shrimp, and white fish in a buttery paprika glaze
Seafood Medley in 20 Minutes
  • Total20 Mins
  • Protein53 g
  • Calories420 kcal
This seafood medley utilizes staggered searing to maintain the tenderness of the fish. To prevent the shrimp from becoming rubbery, each component is cooked based on its density.
  • Time: 10 min active + 10 min cooking
  • Flavor & Texture: Rich, garlic-forward buttery sauce with deeply seared deep amber edges
  • Perfect for: An elegant weeknight meal that is both quick and impressive

Quick Pan-Seared Seafood Medley

Rubbery shrimp and soggy, white fish often ruin a pan-sear. Most people throw everything in the pan at once, which drops the temperature and causes the seafood to steam in its own juices instead of browning.

The trick is to cook in stages and keep everything bone-dry. By searing the scallops first, you get that deep crust without overcooking the more delicate cod or shrimp.

When making a seafood medley, the contrast between the crisp edges and the buttery sauce is what makes it. You get a hit of smoky paprika and bright lemon that cuts through the rich butter.

Why the Staging Works

  • Staged Searing: Cooking in order of density ensures the scallops get a crust while the shrimp stay plump.
  • Surface Dryness: Moisture creates steam. Patting everything dry allows the pan to sear the seafood immediately.
  • Acid Deglazing: Using fish stock and lemon juice lifts the browned bits from the pan to create a rich glaze.

Ingredients & Substitutes

  • 1/2 lb sea scallops
  • 1/2 lb medium shrimp, peeled and deveined
  • 1/2 lb cod or halibut, cubed into 1-inch pieces
  • 1/2 tsp salt
  • 1/2 tsp black pepper
  • 1/2 tsp smoked paprika Why this? Adds a campfire depth that balances the butter
  • 1/2 tsp garlic powder
  • 2 tbsp unsalted butter
  • 1 tbsp olive oil
  • 3 garlic cloves, minced
  • 1/4 cup fish stock
  • 1 tbsp fresh lemon juice Why this? Cuts the fat and brightens the fish
  • 1 tbsp fresh parsley, chopped
Original IngredientSubstituteWhy It Works
Cod or HalibutTilapia or BassComparable mild flavor. Note: Tilapia is thinner and cooks faster
Fish StockVegetable StockActs as a neutral base. Note: Lacks the briny depth of seafood stock

The Gear You Need

Just a few basic tools are required. Opt for a skillet (12 inches) made of cast iron or stainless steel, as non-stick pans don't brown the scallops as effectively. A fish spatula is ideal for flipping the tender cod without breaking the chunks. You'll also need a meat thermometer to monitor internal temperatures.

The Cooking Process

Getting the Prep Right

Thoroughly pat the fish chunks and scallops dry with paper towels. For those using a frozen seafood medley, ensure it is fully thawed and dried again, as excess moisture prevents a proper sear.

In a bowl, combine the scallops, shrimp, and fish with 1/2 tsp salt, 1/2 tsp black pepper, 1/2 tsp smoked paprika, and 1/2 tsp garlic powder, tossing until well coated.

Raw scallops, shrimp, and fish chunks coated in red seasoning in a bowl.

Searing in Stages

Heat a 12-inch skillet over medium-high. Combine 1 tbsp olive oil and 1 tbsp unsalted butter, heating until the butter foams and starts to brown.

Add the scallops to the pan. Let them sear for 2 minutes undisturbed until a chestnut brown crust forms. Flip them and cook for 2 more minutes, then remove them from the pan.

Add the fish and shrimp to the pan. Sear for 2–3 minutes, tossing occasionally, until shrimp are opaque and pink and a thermometer reads 145°F (63°C). You can find more USDA seafood temperature guidelines here. Remove and set aside with the scallops.

Chef: To get the best result with a seafood medley, avoid overcrowding the pan. Too many pieces at once will release moisture, causing the seafood to boil rather than sear.

Seared scallops with a brown crust in a skillet.

Finishing the Sauce

Reduce the heat to medium. Stir in the final 1 tbsp unsalted butter and 3 cloves of minced garlic, sautéing for 30–60 seconds until fragrant.

Add 1 tbsp fresh lemon juice and 1/4 cup fish stock. Stir continuously for 1–2 minutes until the liquid reduces into a velvety glaze.

Place all the seared seafood back into the pan. Gently toss for 30 seconds to coat everything in the sauce, then finish with 1 tbsp chopped fresh parsley.

A reduced lemon and fish stock glaze bubbling in a skillet.

Problems and Solutions

If your seafood tastes rubbery, it's almost always due to overcooking or overcrowding. Let the seafood sit undisturbed during the first part of the sear. Stirring too early prevents the crust from forming.

When the sauce stays watery, it means it didn't reduce enough. Keep simmering for another minute before adding the seafood back in.

ProblemRoot CauseSolution
Rubbery ShrimpOvercookedRemove as soon as they turn opaque pink
No BrowningWet seafood or low heatPat dry with towels and wait for butter to foam
Fish BreakingStirring too muchFlip once or twice with a fish spatula

Swaps and Add-Ins

This is a seafood medley easy enough to customize based on what's fresh at the market. If you want to change this seafood medley, try adding a splash of heavy cream at the end for a richer sauce. You can also turn this into a seafood medley soup by adding 2 cups of additional fish stock and a pinch of thyme.

For a seafood medley quick fix, use pre-cut frozen fillets, but ensure they are patted dry. If you prefer a seafood medley homemade style with more veg, sauté some diced zucchini or asparagus before adding the garlic.

StyleModificationResult
CreamyAdd 2 tbsp heavy creamRicher, thicker sauce
SpicyAdd 1/4 tsp red pepper flakesGentle heat in the butter
MediterraneanAdd 1 tbsp capersBriny, salty pop

Storing Your Leftovers

Keep the seafood medley in a sealed glass jar in the fridge for up to 2 days. Seafood doesn't freeze well once cooked, as the texture becomes mushy.

To reheat, avoid the microwave. Place the seafood in a skillet over low heat with a splash of water or fish stock to loosen the sauce. Heat gently until the seafood reaches an internal temperature of 165°F (74°C), which keeps the shrimp from turning rubbery.

Best Side Pairings

Sautéed scallops and shrimp with flaky white fish in a glossy lemon-garlic sauce served on a minimalist plate

This dish is very versatile. For a full meal, it works perfectly as a seafood medley pasta recipe when tossed with linguine and a bit of pasta water. You can also serve it over a bed of basmati rice or with a crusty piece of sourdough to soak up the garlic butter.

If you're looking for a lighter option, a side of sautéed spinach or roasted asparagus balances the richness of the butter. For those who like a seafood medley pasta, just boil your noodles and toss them into the pan right before returning the seafood.

High in Sodium

⚠️

810 mg of sodium per serving (35% of daily value)

American Heart Association recommendation: no more than 2,300 mg of sodium per day

Tips to Reduce Sodium

  • 🧂Reduce Added Salt

    Omit or significantly reduce the 1/2 tsp of salt, as the seafood and stock already contain natural sodium.

  • 🥣Swap the Fish Stock

    Replace the standard fish stock with a low-sodium version or use water with a pinch of extra lemon zest for flavor.

  • 🍋Increase Citrus

    Add an extra squeeze of fresh lemon juice to brighten the dish, which helps mimic the taste of salt.

  • 🧄Enhance Aromatics

    Increase the amount of minced garlic or add sautéed shallots to build a more robust flavor profile.

  • 🌿Use More Fresh Herbs

    Double the amount of fresh parsley or add fresh dill to provide a burst of flavor without adding any sodium.

Good to Know

Why does the shrimp turn rubbery, and when should it come off the heat?

Overcooking causes the proteins to tighten and toughen.

Tip: Remove the shrimp from the pan as soon as they become opaque and pink.

Will moisture prevent the scallops from browning?

Excess surface water creates steam that blocks the formation of a chestnut brown crust.

Tip: Pat the scallops completely dry with paper towels before seasoning.

Does crowding the pan cause the seafood to steam instead of sear?

Too many items in the pan lower the temperature and release too much moisture at once.

Tip: Sear the scallops first and remove them to ensure the pan remains hot for the shrimp and fish.

How do I store leftovers?

Put the seafood in a sealed glass jar in the fridge for up to 2 days.

Tip: Reheat in a skillet over low heat with a splash of fish stock to loosen the sauce.

Can I use a different white fish for this medley?

Any firm white fish works well as long as it is cut into 1-inch chunks.

Tip: Halibut is a great alternative to cod for a slightly meatier texture.

Seafood Medley in 20 Minutes

Seafood Medley in 20 Minutes Recipe Card
Seafood Medley in 20 Minutes Recipe Card
4.4 / 5 (27 Reviews)
Preparation time:10 Mins
Cooking time:10 Mins
Servings:2 servings
Category: Main CourseCuisine: Coastal
print Pin

Ingredients:

Instructions:

Nutrition Facts
Per serving
Calories
420 kcal
% Daily Value*
Total Fat 21g
   Saturated Fat 7.5g
Sodium 810mg
Total Carbohydrate 5g
   Dietary Fiber 1g
   Total Sugars 2g
Protein 53g
* Percent Daily Values are based on a 2,000 calorie diet.
Rate This Recipe
Pick your stars
Share & Rate:
Submit Review:
How Readers Rated It
5
(16)
4
(8)
3
(2)
2
(0)
1
(1)
Jump to Recipe