Food Headline Medicine Watch shaken baby syndrome

How an Elite Group of Pediatric Radiologists Started Medical Kidnapping in the 1940s

Caffey old news article on SBS
Caffey old news article on SBS

Dr. John Patrick Caffey was born in Utah in 1895, the yr that Wilhelm Conrad Roentgen by chance found the x-ray, which was initially generally known as the “roentgen ray.” The influence of Dr. John Caffey on medical kidnappings of at present can’t be underestimated. Photograph supply.

By Well being Impression Information/ Employees

“The bones tell the story,” or so the saying goes. However do they inform the full story?

The discovery of the x-ray in 1895 gave rise to a gaggle of docs who claimed to have the ability to learn the x-rays and discover the delicate indicators of youngster abuse that everyone else missed.

It took many years for his or her rhetoric to be accepted by the public, however when it was lastly embraced, it was not lengthy after that The Baby Abuse Prevention and Remedy Act of 1974 (CAPTA) was handed by a bipartisan Congress, establishing what we now know as Youngster Protecting Providers.

Most historians hint the trendy period of Youngster Welfare to the landmark paper, “The Battered-Child Syndrome” by Dr. C. Henry Kempe and his colleagues, revealed in 1962.


Has the U.S. Develop into a Medical Police State? How Docs Deny Due Course of to Kidnap Youngsters Via CPS

From Baby Safety to State-sponsored Baby Kidnapping: How Did we Get Right here?

The paper types the theoretical framework upon which assumptions by Baby Abuse Pediatricians of at this time are based mostly, as much as and together with language to bypass any various explanations that oldsters and different docs might current.

Regardless of how a lot strong medical and scientific analysis goes into rebutting the allegation that the baby was abused, the foregone conclusion by Youngster Abuse Pediatricians is that it’s incorrect.

Dr. John Caffey Established His Breed of Docs as “The Experts” in Baby Abuse – in the 1940s

The historical past of the paper, and this line of considering, owes its roots to a person named Dr. John Patrick Caffey who was born in Utah in 1895, the yr that Wilhelm Conrad Roentgen by accident found the x-ray, which was initially often known as the “roentgen ray.”

After coaching in inner drugs and pediatrics, he practiced at Infants Hospital in New York as a pediatrician.


Dr. Caffey wrote an influential paper on Shaken Child Syndrome in 1972. Photograph supply.

In the meantime, the subject of radiology, the medical specialty of utilizing imaging resembling x-rays in the apply of drugs, was in its infancy. There was just one full-time pediatric radiologist in the complete United States in the early 1920s.

As a pediatrician, Dr. Caffey attended occasional radiology conferences, however he turned annoyed after attending one such convention, which was taught by a pathologist, not a radiologist.

His remark that it was “another hour wasted” was overheard by Infants Hospital’s chief of pediatrics, who requested him if he thought he might do higher. He reportedly answered that he “could hardly do worse.”

Consequently, he was put in cost of the hospital’s radiology division in 1929. In accordance with the Society for Pediatric Radiology web site:

He started to comprehend that the area was vast open for a doctor of scholarly bent and pediatric background, and he seized his alternative. He quickly taught himself the vary of regular appearances and the plain-film manifestations of youngsters’s illnesses. [Emphasis added.]

He revealed the first version of the Pediatric X-Ray Analysis textbook in 1945. He outlined what was regular.

The subsequent yr he revealed an article in the American Journal of Roentgenology that examined the case research of 6 infants admitted to his hospital with subdural hematoma. X-rays confirmed that the infants additionally had a number of lengthy bone fractures.

Subdural hematoma (mind bleeding) is one of the “triad” – the three signs upon which docs assume a child has been shaken. Damaged bones in infants, even infants with documented circumstances of bone fragility, are assumed to be baby abuse.

Typically damaged bones and shaken child signs are seen in the similar youngster.

With this text, Caffey invited radiologists and paediatricians to be extra conscious of the risk that violence was, albeit sometimes, purposefully inflicted upon youngsters.

Caffey established himself, and the self-discipline of paediatric radiology, as radical, progressive and unafraid to attract what have been, for this era, daring conclusions about baby maltreatment.

Authority in diagnosing the bodily mistreatment of youngsters by adults was thus concentrated inside the professions of paediatrics and radiology.

Constructing on Caffey’s early work, these professions consolidated their standing as ‘experts’ in managing baby battering in each Britain and America over the following 20 years. (Supply.)

Thus, Caffey’s paper shaped the root of declaring that pediatric radiologists have been THE specialists in baby abuse, lengthy earlier than Dr. Kempe’s 1962 paper and the board certification of Baby Abuse Pediatricians which started in 2010.

Caffey’s Junior Assistant Discovers “Unrecognized Skeletal Trauma”

Dr. Frederick Silverman educated at Yale College as a pediatrician. From 1945 to 1947, he educated underneath Dr. John Caffey at Infants Hospital in New York – the similar time interval throughout which Caffey revealed his paper and e-book. He turned Caffey’s junior assistant.

Dr. Fred Silverman

Dr. Fred Silverman – Photograph Supply.

From there, Silverman turned the Director of the Division of Roentgenolgy at Cincinnati Youngsters’s Hospital in 1947.

He revealed a paper in 1953 entitled, “The Roentgen Manifestations of Unrecognized Skeletal Trauma in Infants,” in the American Journal of Roentgenology. He famous basic metaphyseal lesions in three infants with accidents just like these in Caffey’s research.

Silverman concluded that the bone fractures have been clearly the end result of a number of traumatic accidents.

Consequently, he urged physicians to realize correct affected person histories, emphasising that oldsters might ‘permit trauma and be unaware of it, may recognize trauma but forget or be reluctant to admit it, or may deliberately injure the child and deny it.’ (Supply.)

Caffey later joined Silverman to work with him at Cincinnati Youngsters’s Hospital.

Dr. Silverman collaborated as one of the contributing authors of Dr. C. Henry Kempe’s paper, “The Battered-Child Syndrome” in 1962.

Silverman moved to Stanford College Medical Middle in California in 1976 the place he served as professor emeritus of radiology and practiced at Lucile Salter Packard Youngsters’s Hospital for 25 years.

Dr. Edward Neuhauser

Dr. Edward Neuhauser was born in 1908 and educated in orthopedics. He turned “disenchanted” with that subject and thought of different choices together with tugboat captain earlier than deciding to enter radiology. In accordance with Radiology:

In 1941, with out finishing his residency, Dr. Neuhauser turned director of radiology at Youngsters’s Hospital, Boston. (Supply.)

He turned a prolific author of medical articles and a charismatic instructor of medical college students. In 1949, he “established the world’s first regular pediatric radiology fellowship.” (Supply.)

Apparently, he gained the Jurzykowski Award in Medical Science for “work in the diagnosis of Wilm’s tumor.” (Supply.)

Wilms tumor is the analysis that was given, earlier than any biopsy or lab testing was finished, to little Grace Beabout, a earlier story we coated on See:

California Mother and father Lose Custody of 2-Yr Previous Daughter When Asking for a Second Opinion Earlier than Eradicating Youngster’s Kidney

Unique Group of Pediatric Radiologists Is Shaped

As the subject of pediatric radiology continued to develop, considerations have been rising in the common public over the dangers of radiation from x-rays, as nuclear weapons have been being examined above floor in locations like Nevada and the Soviet Union.

There have been talks amongst Caffey and his colleagues about how these docs would work with the American Academy of Pediatrics and what path they might take.

In what members later known as a “jam session,” a gaggle of docs obtained collectively for a day of discussions on April 21, 1958, the day earlier than the opening of the annual assembly of the American Roentgen Ray Society in Washington, DC.

Solely a choose group of American and Canadian docs, principally pediatric radiologists, have been invited to the occasion.

In line with the Society for Pediatric Radiology web site:

Although it might haven’t any official reference to the pediatric session, the American Roentgen Ray Society would offer viewboxes, a lantern slide projector, and a blackboard. The assembly wouldn’t be publicized to the basic membership of the American Roentgen Ray Society.

There have been solely 9 individuals current at the unique assembly, which was carried out with no printed agenda.

The Society of Pediatric Radiology was established that day, they usually met once more on September 29 of the similar yr.

This time there have been 33 physicians in attendance, “including 11 who later became president of the society.”

Dr. Neuhauser turned the first president, elected by attendees:

…maybe as a result of greater than half of the constitution members had spent a while in Boston underneath his pedagogical spell.

Dr. Silverman was named president-elect, not solely as a result of of his excellent qualifications and his shut ties to Dr. Caffey (who was not current), but in addition as a result of he practiced in Cincinnati, the website of the subsequent assembly of the American Roentgen Ray Society.

Guidelines have been established over the subsequent yr, together with a provision that membership can be restricted to:

…people with a main curiosity in pediatric radiology and must be restricted to 100.

Half or all of the assembly ought to be closed to everybody however members and contributing visitors.

There isn’t any point out of who these “contributing guests” have been, what their agenda was, or what they contributed.

founding members Society for Pediatric Radiology pedrad dot org

Drs. Neuhauser, Caffey, Holt, Silverman, and Taybi at the 1975 assembly of the Society for Pediatric Radiology in Atlanta, Georgia. Supply.

Drs. Caffey, Silverman, and Neuhauser every remained concerned with the society over the years.

Society Provides Rise to “The Battered-Child Syndrome” Landmark Paper

It was not lengthy after the formation of the Society for Pediatric Radiology in 1958 that Dr. C. Henry Kempe revealed the beforehand talked about paper, “The Battered-Child Syndrome” in 1962.

Dr. Kempe was born Karl Heinz Kempe in what’s now Poland on April 6, 1922. He was a Jewish boy born in what was then Germany shortly earlier than the rise of Adolf Hitler and the Nazis. He got here to the United States in 1939 at the age of 17 after the struggle broke out. The Holocaust had already begun.

Earlier than he fled the horrors occurring in his homeland, a physician had taken him beneath his wing and impressed him to study drugs. Kempe was accepted into medical faculty at the College of California, the place he studied pediatrics.

In 1948, he turned an assistant in pediatrics at Yale.

After his 1962 paper which he wrote with different docs together with Dr. Silverman, he collaborated with Dr. Ray E. Helfer on a e-book entitled, The Battered Youngster. He went on to discovered the Nationwide Middle for the Prevention and Remedy of Baby Abuse and Neglect.

Dr. Helfer thought-about Dr. Kempe to be his mentor. The Ray E. Helfer Society, an elite group of Baby Abuse Pediatricians, was later based in 1999.

ray_helfer_picture (2)

Dr. Ray E. Helfer, founder of the elite Helfer Society of Youngster Abuse Pediatricians, was mentored by Dr. Kempe. Supply.

X-Rays Have By no means Advised the Entire Image

These docs, papers, and the societies that shaped round them served to determine pediatric radiologists as the “experts” on youngster abuse, and x-rays as the main device to diagnose abuse, particularly when nobody else was intelligent sufficient to acknowledge that the baby had been abused.

It was all very interesting to docs, social staff, and attorneys who needed a definitive magic bullet to determine youngster abusers. By writing papers that decreed the experience of radiologists as the correct identifiers of abuse, dissent and opposition have been successfully shut down.

The marketing campaign to discredit docs who disagreed with their interpretation of the knowledge was begun many many years earlier than the Helfer Society started their current media instructional marketing campaign described in our earlier article right here.

The arguments that oldsters falsely accused of youngster abuse face in right now’s courtrooms started earlier than their very own mother and father have been born.

These arguments have all the time been challenged by docs, researchers, scientists, and others who understood from the starting that x-rays and different diagnostic imaging instruments are simply that – instruments.

They don’t seem to be sufficient to “provide an objective measure of child abuse, but rather must be used merely as one indicator alongside” different proof. (Supply.)

It Goes Again to Funding and Energy

As numerous youngster abuse societies have been established in consequence of the efforts of early pediatric radiologists, the mindset of the public and legislators started to vary:

Probably the most vital end result of these worldwide discussions was not in altering the particular development of the battered youngster syndrome, however in enabling a small and disparate group of switch brokers to mutually reassure each other of the elementary necessity for additional analysis into baby battering. (Supply.)

Radiologists rose as much as be established as the specialists capable of diagnose baby abuse, regardless of plentiful analysis by different medical professionals which rebuts their conclusions.

Jennifer Crane paperwork what she calls  the “invention” of the battered baby syndrome:

Kempe initially ‘discovered’ this situation and positioned radiologists as the main diagnostic agent.

She says that:

…radiologists have been notably profitable in negotiating themselves a key position in the identification of baby battering….

In Britain, the publication of ‘The Battered Child Syndrome’ noticed radiologists search to direct funding and assets to their more and more costly career. (Supply.)

Pediatric radiologists have been the unique “Child Abuse Pediatricians” who cleverly positioned themselves in such a approach as to guarantee the continuation of the demand for his or her providers, in addition to to safe a endless move of donations from non-profits in addition to federal dollars for his or her continued analysis into circumstances that, typically, they made up, to the detriment of harmless households in the United States and round the world.

Touch upon this text at

Medical Kidnapping: A Menace to Each Household in America T-Shirt


100% Pre-shrunk Cotton!
Order right here!

Medical Kidnapping is REAL!

See: Medical Kidnapping: A Menace to Each Household in America Immediately

Assist unfold the consciousness of Medical Kidnapping by sporting the Medical Kidnapping t-shirt!

Help the trigger of, which is a component of the Well being Influence Information community.

Order right here!

If you recognize people who find themselves skeptical and can’t consider that medical kidnapping occurs in the U.S. at this time, that is the e-book for them! Backed with strong references and actual life examples, they will be unable to disclaim the plain proof earlier than them, and can develop into higher educated on this matter that’s destroying the American household.

Medical Kidnapping final

1 Ebook – 228 pages
Retail: $24.99
FREE Delivery Obtainable!
Now: $14.99
Order right here!


2 Books
Retail: $49.98 (for two books)
FREE Delivery Out there!
Now: $19.99 (for two books)
Order right here!

Additionally out there as eBook:


eBook – Obtain Instantly!

Revealed on November 20, 2018

s.parentNode.insertBefore(t,s)(window, doc,’script’,
fbq(‘init’, ‘928755773879843’);